Dragon Quest localization history: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
The various English localizations of the [[Dragon Quest]] series, as a result of three eras of Dragon Quest in North America by [[Enix]] and [[Square Enix]], has resulted in a '''localization lack of uniformity''' in North America. This article will list the causes and effects of the localization changes that Enix and Square Enix have made since the first English release of ''[[Dragon Warrior|Dragon Quest]]''. | The various English localizations of the [[Dragon Quest]] series, as a result of three eras of Dragon Quest in North America by [[Enix]] and [[Square Enix]], has resulted in a '''localization lack of uniformity''' in North America. This article will list the causes and effects of the localization changes that Enix and Square Enix have made since the first English release of ''[[Dragon Warrior|Dragon Quest]]''. | ||
== | ==Nintendo, Dragon Warrior, and Enix America Corporation== | ||
''See also [[Localization Differences#Enix America Corporation|Localization Differences of Enix America Corporation]]'' | ''See also [[Localization Differences#Enix America Corporation|Localization Differences of Enix America Corporation]]'' | ||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
It also meant that many new, younger gamers weren't exposed to the series. And as the Final Fantasy games increased in popularity with it's new Super Nintendo titles being released stateside, '''[[Dragon Quest|Dragon Warrior]]''' was starting to fade into obscurity. It was only through sites such as [[Dragon's Den]] and the [[DQShrine.com|DQShrine]] that fans in North America found each other and kept hopes of a return of Dragon Warrior to North America. It was also at this time that many North American fans began refering to the series as '''Dragon Quest''', '''DraQue''' or simply '''DQ'''. | It also meant that many new, younger gamers weren't exposed to the series. And as the Final Fantasy games increased in popularity with it's new Super Nintendo titles being released stateside, '''[[Dragon Quest|Dragon Warrior]]''' was starting to fade into obscurity. It was only through sites such as [[Dragon's Den]] and the [[DQShrine.com|DQShrine]] that fans in North America found each other and kept hopes of a return of Dragon Warrior to North America. It was also at this time that many North American fans began refering to the series as '''Dragon Quest''', '''DraQue''' or simply '''DQ'''. | ||
===Dragon Warrior Monsters | ===Eidos, Dragon Warrior Monsters, Enix America, Inc.=== | ||
''See also [[Localization Differences#Enix America, Inc.|Localization Differences of Enix America, Inc.]]'' | ''See also [[Localization Differences#Enix America, Inc.|Localization Differences of Enix America, Inc.]]'' | ||
In 2000 '''Dragon Warrior''' miraculously returned in the form of ''[[Dragon Warrior Monsters]]'' for the [[Game Boy Color]], which helped to immerse several new American fans into the series. The game was followed by a reestablishment of Enix in North America, as [[Enix America, Inc.]], which released Game Boy remakes of ''[[Dragon Warrior I & II]]'', ''[[Dragon Warrior III (GBC)|Dragon Warrior III]]'', a dual version ''[[Dragon Quest Monsters 2]]'', ''[[Torneko: The Last Hope]]'', and the much anticipated ''[[Dragon Warrior VII]]''. The games' translation was also improved, with the names of characters and such being more faithful to the Japanese version (one example being that the legendary hero [[Erdrick]] was renamed Loto, which was a more faithful translation of his Japanese name, Roto.) By then, Enix had established their own localization for the series. And while the localization was far from perfect, it was still "close enough" to the Japanese version for fans to truly enjoy it. The names of characters, monsters, spells, items, places, etc., had been chosen carefully to reflect the Japanese names, while still maintaining many traditions that had been established since the days of the Nintendo NES. While the localization did suffer somewhat, the fans were still satisfied with it, and all the names used in the English versions were burned into their hearts and minds. As Enix continued to release the Dragon Warrior titles in America, it seemed as though the series was here to stay. But then, something unimaginable happened. | In 2000 '''Dragon Warrior''' miraculously returned in the form of ''[[Dragon Warrior Monsters]]'' for the [[Game Boy Color]], which helped to immerse several new American fans into the series. The game was followed by a reestablishment of Enix in North America, as [[Enix America, Inc.]], which released Game Boy remakes of ''[[Dragon Warrior I & II]]'', ''[[Dragon Warrior III (GBC)|Dragon Warrior III]]'', a dual version ''[[Dragon Quest Monsters 2]]'', ''[[Torneko: The Last Hope]]'', and the much anticipated ''[[Dragon Warrior VII]]''. The games' translation was also improved, with the names of characters and such being more faithful to the Japanese version (one example being that the legendary hero [[Erdrick]] was renamed Loto, which was a more faithful translation of his Japanese name, Roto.) By then, Enix had established their own localization for the series. And while the localization was far from perfect, it was still "close enough" to the Japanese version for fans to truly enjoy it. The names of characters, monsters, spells, items, places, etc., had been chosen carefully to reflect the Japanese names, while still maintaining many traditions that had been established since the days of the Nintendo NES. While the localization did suffer somewhat, the fans were still satisfied with it, and all the names used in the English versions were burned into their hearts and minds. As Enix continued to release the Dragon Warrior titles in America, it seemed as though the series was here to stay. But then, something unimaginable happened. | ||
==Enix Merges with Square, Dragon Quest VIII, and the Current SQUARE ENIX== | |||
''See also [[Localization Differences#Square Enix|Localization Differences of Square Enix]]'' | |||
On April 3rd 2003, Enix and Square merged into one company to form '''[[Square Enix]]'''. Many fans were ecstatic about the merger, and had high hopes for the series' future. Perhaps now that Square and Enix had become one, Dragon Quest would finally get the recognition it deserved, or so many thought. Little did we know just what the new [[Square Enix, Inc.|Square Enix USA]] had in store for our beloved series. | On April 3rd 2003, Enix and Square merged into one company to form '''[[Square Enix]]'''. Many fans were ecstatic about the merger, and had high hopes for the series' future. Perhaps now that Square and Enix had become one, Dragon Quest would finally get the recognition it deserved, or so many thought. Little did we know just what the new [[Square Enix, Inc.|Square Enix USA]] had in store for our beloved series. | ||
Shortly after the merger, the fans began asking questions about the future of Dragon Quest in America, and if we would be getting the Enix designed [[Dragon Quest V (PS2)|PS2 remake of ''Dragon Quest V'']]. However, most of the people in the newly formed Square Enix USA were former Square employees, many of whom had never even heard of Dragon Quest before the merger, and didn't really seem to care. The fans were crushed. It seemed as though their voices were falling on deaf ears, and the future of Dragon Quest looked bleak. But when Square Enix announced that ''[[Dragon Quest VIII]]'' for the PS2 would be coming to the states, the fans once again rejoiced! But their rejoicing wouldn't last long, as the game's English localization had the fans confused and dismayed at the several changes that were made which contradicted both the old Enix naming conventions and the original Japanese. While some of the changes were welcomed, others were not. The changes of names and writing style proved to be very upsetting to fans who have become so familiar with the Enix translations, and who had expected Square Enix to carry on the traditions that had already been established when the series was known as Dragon Warrior. This brought frustration to many long time fans who almost felt insulted by Square Enix for their new, and sometimes awkward, translation. It is not known if any of those in charge of the localization process had tried playing any of the Dragon Warrior games prior to translating ''Dragon Quest VIII'', but it certainly would have helped if they had. | |||
Shortly after the merger, the fans began asking questions about the future of Dragon Quest in America, and if we would be getting the [[Dragon Quest V (PS2)|PS2 remake of ''Dragon Quest V'']]. However, most of the people in the newly formed Square Enix USA were former Square employees, many of whom had never even heard of Dragon Quest before the merger, and didn't really seem to care. The fans were crushed. It seemed as though their voices were falling on deaf ears, and the future of Dragon Quest looked bleak. But when Square Enix announced that ''[[Dragon Quest VIII]]'' for the PS2 would be | |||
coming to the states, the fans once again rejoiced! But their rejoicing wouldn't last long, as the game's English localization had the fans confused and dismayed at the several changes that were made which contradicted both the old Enix naming conventions and the original Japanese. While some of the changes were welcomed, others were not. The changes of names and writing style proved to be very upsetting to fans who have become so familiar with the Enix translations, and who had expected Square Enix to carry on the traditions that had already been established when the series was known as Dragon Warrior. This brought frustration to many long time fans who almost felt insulted by Square Enix for their new, and sometimes awkward, translation. It is not known if any of those in charge of the localization process had tried playing any of the Dragon Warrior games prior to translating ''Dragon Quest VIII'', but it certainly would have helped if they had. | |||
Not all of the changes were so bad. For one thing, some parts of the game were actually closer to the original Japanese, and taking any steps to achieve closer unity to the original Japanese counterpart is always welcome (Well, at least by most.) But some of the other changes are so pointless and far away from the Japanese version, it makes you wonder if they gave any consideration to the Japanese at all! | Not all of the changes were so bad. For one thing, some parts of the game were actually closer to the original Japanese, and taking any steps to achieve closer unity to the original Japanese counterpart is always welcome (Well, at least by most.) But some of the other changes are so pointless and far away from the Japanese version, it makes you wonder if they gave any consideration to the Japanese at all! | ||
==Current Square Enix Localization of Dragon Quest== | ===Current Square Enix Localization of Dragon Quest=== | ||
The follwing sections will take a look at how the series was altered from both it's American and Japanese traditions, almost to the point of being unrecognizable at times, as well as point out some of the advantages of the new localization over the old. The purpose of this article is NOT to bash Square Enix, but to evaluate how they've handled the localization, and what the fans | The follwing sections will take a look at how the series was altered from both it's American and Japanese traditions, almost to the point of being unrecognizable at times, as well as point out some of the advantages of the new localization over the old. The purpose of this article is NOT to bash Square Enix, but to evaluate how they've handled the localization, and what the fans | ||
have to say about it. | have to say about it. | ||
===Voice Acting & Script Writing=== | ====Voice Acting & Script Writing==== | ||
First, let's begin with ''Dragon Quest VIII'', the first Dragon Quest game localized by Square | First, let's begin with ''Dragon Quest VIII'', the first Dragon Quest game localized by Square | ||
| Line 65: | Line 64: | ||
new script doesn't quite seem to capture the spirit of Dragon Quest, and many feel Square Enix in North America doesn't truly understand the series all that well. It feels like they're trying to take a traditional Japanese RPG, and put a Western "spin" on it if you will, by changing the script around to make it feel less Japanese and more british-style. Now anyone whose played a good amount of JRPGs know that the Japanese have a different way of thinking than the western world does. And when JRPGs get localized for an English release, they should remain as faithful to the original Japanese as much as is nesseccary. It is understood that they have to go through some sort of "Westernization" when brought over to the states, but they still need to retain their Japanese idendity, and localizers shouldn't be changing names around for no reason! Especially when some of the new names the come up with aren't even that good! | new script doesn't quite seem to capture the spirit of Dragon Quest, and many feel Square Enix in North America doesn't truly understand the series all that well. It feels like they're trying to take a traditional Japanese RPG, and put a Western "spin" on it if you will, by changing the script around to make it feel less Japanese and more british-style. Now anyone whose played a good amount of JRPGs know that the Japanese have a different way of thinking than the western world does. And when JRPGs get localized for an English release, they should remain as faithful to the original Japanese as much as is nesseccary. It is understood that they have to go through some sort of "Westernization" when brought over to the states, but they still need to retain their Japanese idendity, and localizers shouldn't be changing names around for no reason! Especially when some of the new names the come up with aren't even that good! | ||
===What's in a Name=== | ====What's in a Name==== | ||
One very peculiar aspect of the new tranlsation, is that many monsters have been renamed without much regard to the traditional Japanese names. For instance, there is a monster called Battle Rex in the Japanese version of the series. And when Enix localized the Dragon Warrior games, they left it's name the same. But for Square Enix's new Dragon Quest localization, they changed his name from Battle Rex to hacksaurus instead. Why would Square Enix change a name that is perfectly understandable in English to something else? Changing a name like Battle Rex to hacksaurus is just plain pointless! | One very peculiar aspect of the new tranlsation, is that many monsters have been renamed without much regard to the traditional Japanese names. For instance, there is a monster called Battle Rex in the Japanese version of the series. And when Enix localized the Dragon Warrior games, they left it's name the same. But for Square Enix's new Dragon Quest localization, they changed his name from Battle Rex to hacksaurus instead. Why would Square Enix change a name that is perfectly understandable in English to something else? Changing a name like Battle Rex to hacksaurus is just plain pointless! | ||
| Line 73: | Line 72: | ||
Square Enix also changed almost all the traditional spell names, too. Spells like [[Firebal]] were changed to [[Sizz]] and [[Vivify]] changed to [[Zing]], which doesn't fly over well with fans of the old translation. While this may have been done to reflect the perceived onomatopoeia of the Japanese spell names, some of the new localizations aren't as descriptive as the older Dragon Warrior names. Some changes are believed to be better, for example, [[Return]] was renamed [[Zoom]] and [[Outside]] was renamed [[Evac]]. Square Enix has also changed some of the item names, examples include changing [[Medical Herb]] to [[Medicinal Herb]] and [[Antidote Herb]] to [[Antidotal Herb]]. Many would prefer they had stayed with the traditional names that had already been established by the Dragon Warrior translations. | Square Enix also changed almost all the traditional spell names, too. Spells like [[Firebal]] were changed to [[Sizz]] and [[Vivify]] changed to [[Zing]], which doesn't fly over well with fans of the old translation. While this may have been done to reflect the perceived onomatopoeia of the Japanese spell names, some of the new localizations aren't as descriptive as the older Dragon Warrior names. Some changes are believed to be better, for example, [[Return]] was renamed [[Zoom]] and [[Outside]] was renamed [[Evac]]. Square Enix has also changed some of the item names, examples include changing [[Medical Herb]] to [[Medicinal Herb]] and [[Antidote Herb]] to [[Antidotal Herb]]. Many would prefer they had stayed with the traditional names that had already been established by the Dragon Warrior translations. | ||
===Do You Hear What I Hear?=== | ====Do You Hear What I Hear?==== | ||
In ''Dragon Quest VIII'', Square Enix also removed all of the traditional battle and spell sound effects, which have been around since the very first Dragon Quest game, and replaced them with new sound effects of their own. This came as a shock and great displeasure to fans who had come to expect the traditional sounds effects that were a staple in the series. Removing these sound effects makes the game feel less like Dragon Quest, and most were not happy to see them removed. Thankfully, Square Enix repented and now all of the Dragon Quest games released in the states after ''Dragon Quest VIII'' maintain their traditional sounds. | In ''Dragon Quest VIII'', Square Enix also removed all of the traditional battle and spell sound effects, which have been around since the very first Dragon Quest game, and replaced them with new sound effects of their own. This came as a shock and great displeasure to fans who had come to expect the traditional sounds effects that were a staple in the series. Removing these sound effects makes the game feel less like Dragon Quest, and most were not happy to see them removed. Thankfully, Square Enix repented and now all of the Dragon Quest games released in the states after ''Dragon Quest VIII'' maintain their traditional sounds. | ||
===God is in His Heavens, All is Not Well with Square Enix=== | ====God is in His Heavens, All is Not Well with Square Enix==== | ||
In Square Enix's new localization, all references to [[God]] are replaced with [[Goddess]], and | In Square Enix's new localization, all references to [[God]] are replaced with [[Goddess]], and | ||